Determining Liability for Defective Products Cases [2025 Guide]

Understanding Product Liability Claims

Product liability is a legal principle that holds parties involved in producing and distributing a product responsible for injuries or damages caused by defects in that product.

A potential product liability case arises when a product is designed, manufactured, or sold in a way that makes it unsafe for consumers, leading to harm or injury.

Product liability lawsuits involve various types of defects, including design defects (flaws in the product’s design), manufacturing defects (errors during the manufacturing process), and marketing defects (failure to warn or provide adequate instructions).

Parties Potentially Responsible for Defective Products

One of the unique aspects of product liability suits is that responsibility can fall on different parties across the supply chain.

Ways that each party could assume liability for product liability cases includes:

• Product manufacturers
• Component suppliers
• Product distributors
• Retailers

Product Manufacturers

The manufacturer is often the primary party responsible in a product liability lawsuit, as they design and produce the product.

They could be liable for a product design defect, a manufacturing error, or an inadequate warning label.

This responsibility includes the original manufacturer as well as the manufacturers of any parts or components that went into the final product.

Component Suppliers

In products made of various components, a defect might not originate from the final assembler or manufacturer but from a supplier of specific parts.

If a vehicle part like an airbag malfunctions, the company that supplied the defective airbag could be held accountable.

Component suppliers are, therefore, often scrutinized in product liability cases to determine if a defect in their parts contributed to the incident.

Product Distributors

Distributors serve as intermediaries, transporting products from manufacturers to retailers.

Even though they don’t make or sell products directly to consumers, they can sometimes be held liable, especially if they were aware of potential risks associated with a product but continued to distribute it.

Retailers

Although retailers are the final point of sale, they too can bear responsibility if they sell defective or dangerous products.

A product liability suit may happen if the retailer fails to remove a recalled product from their shelves, sells an item without sufficient warnings, or fails to properly inspect the goods before sale.

Importance of Identifying the Correct Defendants

In product liability lawsuits, correctly identifying the defendants is crucial to establishing accountability and maximizing potential compensation.

Correctly identifying responsible parties is essential for securing justice and strengthening consumer safety standards across industries.

The success of a product liability case often depends on accurately pinpointing the parties responsible for the defect.

Because different entities in the supply chain handle various aspects of the product’s lifecycle, understanding who was at fault for the defect is key to achieving a favorable outcome.

By holding all liable parties accountable, plaintiffs also increase their chances of receiving fair compensation for their injuries or damages.

Including every responsible party, from the manufacturer to the retailer, ensures a comprehensive approach to recovering these costs.

Types of Product Liability Claims

The grounds for product liability suits generally fall into three main categories, namely, design defects, manufacturing defects, and marketing defects.

Each type addresses a major part of the product cycle to the market and the potential risks inherent in them.

Design Defects

A design defect claim asserts that a product’s design was inherently unsafe before the manufacturer made the product.

This defect means that every product unit has the same dangerous flaw regardless of the manufacturing quality.

Design defects typically involve products where the risks of using the design outweigh its benefits or where the product designer could have used safer alternative designs.

Some examples include:

• A power tool lacking an essential safety guard that could prevent injuries would be considered defective in design.
• A hip implant made with materials prone to wear prematurely, leading to potential complications or further surgeries.
• A toy with small, detachable parts that pose a choking hazard for young children.
• A dresser designed with a high center of gravity that tips over easily, creating a risk of injury, especially for children.

Manufacturing Defects

Manufacturing defect claims focus on errors that occurred during the product’s creation or assembly.

These defects are usually unintentional and may affect only a certain batch of products.

The product’s design is sound, but something went wrong in the manufacturing process, causing some units to be flawed and potentially dangerous.

Some examples include:

• A batch of cars with faulty brakes due to improper assembly or poor-quality materials.
• A batch of medication cross-contaminated with hazardous chemicals during production, leading to unexpected and harmful side effects.
• Packaged foods that contain foreign substances, such as metal or plastic shards, due to errors on the manufacturing line.
• An electric appliance with poorly connected wirings, which increases the risk of electrical shock.

Marketing Defects

Marketing defect claims, sometimes called “failure-to-warn” claims, focus on the manufacturer’s or seller’s duty to provide adequate warnings or instructions.

If a product poses potential risks that aren’t obvious to a user, it’s essential for manufacturers and sellers to provide clear warnings or instructions to ensure safe use.

Some examples include:

• A medication with potential side effects when taken with certain foods but doesn’t carry a warning label.
• A cleaning product without clear warnings about harmful fumes when used in enclosed spaces without adequate ventilation.
• Power equipment sold without adequate safety instructions on safe handling or use, leading to increased risk of injury.
• Small household items, like magnets or batteries, are sold without warnings about the choking hazard they present to children.

How Attorneys Build a Strong Product Liability Case

To succeed in a product liability case, attorneys must typically establish that:

1. The product was defective.
2. The defect made the product unreasonably dangerous.
3. The defect directly caused the consumer’s injury.

Ways that attorneys approach these steps in each type of product liability claim include:

• Investigating the Nature of the Defect: The product liability lawyer begins by analyzing the product itself. Investigators may test the product, review its design specifications, consult experts, examine manufacturing records, and investigate other instances of similar claims or recalls.
• Demonstrating Correlation: Attorneys must establish a direct link between the defect and the injury the consumer sustained. They accomplish this step by gathering evidence such as medical records, accident reports, or eyewitness statements.
• Proving the Defects: This step often requires attorneys to analyze industry standards, review similar products for safety comparisons, and demonstrate that the risks associated with the defect outweigh the benefits.
• Establishing Strict Liability: By identifying the source of the defect, attorneys can ensure that the appropriate party will be held accountable for their negligence.

A successful product liability case hinges on the thoroughness of the investigation into the defect’s nature and impact.

Attorneys need to build a clear, evidence-based narrative that not only identifies the defect but proves its role in causing harm.

The Role of a Product Liability Attorney

A product liability attorney is crucial in helping clients through the legal process of holding companies accountable for defective products that cause injury.

With specialized knowledge, these attorneys guide clients through each stage of a claim — from initial investigation and evidence gathering to negotiations and potential court proceedings.

Roles of a product liability attorney includes:

• Case and Strategy Development: Product liability attorneys begin by evaluating the client’s case to determine if there’s a viable claim. After an initial assessment, the attorney creates a tailored legal strategy, determining the best course of action based on the type of defect.
• Evidence Gathering: Gathering solid evidence is essential to build a strong case. Attorneys help clients collect the necessary documentation, including medical records, photos of the defective product, accident reports, recall notes, and so on.
• Coordinating with Experts: Product liability cases often hinge on technical details, so attorneys frequently collaborate with experts, such as engineers, product designers, safety and compliance officers, and medical experts.
• Negotiating Settlements: Attorneys use evidence to strengthen their negotiating position, emphasizing the extent of the client’s damages and the company’s responsibility.
• Representing Clients in Court: If securing fair compensation is beyond reach, attorneys may escalate the case to court. Attorneys are responsible for delivering opening and closing statements, questioning witnesses, and submitting all relevant evidence.

Product liability attorneys bring legal expertise and handle all aspects of the case, allowing clients to focus on recovery.

These professionals ensure that their client’s rights are protected, counter any tactics used by defense teams to minimize compensation, and maximize the client’s chances of a successful outcome.

How To File a Product Liability Claim

Filing a product liability claim for defective medical devices, food products, packaging materials, or other sellable products entails a series of steps.

The process consumers can follow to file a product liability claim includes:

1. Seek Medical Attention and Document Injuries: Immediate medical attention is the critical first step. Seeking a medical expert to manage the injury’s severity and obtaining medical records are vital evidence to establish damage.
2. Preserve the Product and Related Evidence: Keep the product in its post-incident condition, as it will be your first evidence in the lawsuit. Take photographs or videos of the product, the scene of the accident, and any visible injuries to provide additional documentation.
3. Contact a Product Liability Attorney: Hiring an attorney experienced in product liability can be essential, as they can guide consumers through the process, handle legal paperwork, and protect their rights against well-represented defendants.
4. Gather Evidence and Build the Case: Consumers should work with their attorney to compile all relevant documents, including medical records, receipts, accident reports, and any recall notices for the product. If there is a history of similar injuries caused by the product, the attorney may also investigate prior complaints or lawsuits to strengthen the claim.
5. File a Claim or Lawsuit: With the evidence and expert testimony prepared, the attorney may decide to file a formal product liability claim with the manufacturer’s or distributor’s insurance provider to initiate negotiations for a settlement.
6. Settlement Negotiations: In many cases, companies may settle out of court to avoid the costs and risks associated with a trial. The attorney will negotiate for a fair settlement that addresses all the client’s damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
7. Trial: If the case goes to trial, the attorney will present the evidence, question witnesses, and make a case for full compensation. The court will then decide on the outcome, which could include damages awarded to the consumer if they succeed in proving liability.

While the process can be complicated and time-consuming, following these steps and working with a skilled attorney can help consumers through the intricacies of a product liability claim.

Victims have a higher chance of collecting fair compensation when working with a qualified attorney.

TorHoerman Law: Talk to Our Product Liability Lawyer

Consumer protection laws are established to safeguard the rights of consumers and hold manufacturers accountable for their negligent handling of products.

When customers sustain injuries or damages from their neglect, they may pursue consumer protection claims to receive compensation for their losses.

At TorHoerman Law, our experienced product liability attorneys deeply understand the laws and regulations surrounding these types of claims.

If a defective product has harmed you or a loved one, don’t hesitate to reach out to us at TorHoerman Law.

Our law firm offers free initial consultations.

You can also use our free, on-page chatbot to find out if you qualify for a lawsuit instantly.