FAQ: When is Someone Considered a Negligent Driver? [2024 Guide]

Defining Negligence

The term “negligence” has distinct meanings in ordinary and legal contexts.

Oxford Languages defines negligence as the “failure to take proper care in doing something.”

Ordinary negligence can simply be the failure to lock your front door before leaving or to check the expiration date on food before consuming it.

Negligence means failing to exercise the level of care toward another individual that a reasonable or prudent person would exercise in similar situations.

This “failure to exercise reasonable care” includes both actions and omissions.

This specificity arises from the reliance on the “reasonable person” standard, an objective test the law uses to determine whether an individual’s actions align with what a reasonable person would do in similar circumstances.

There are various types of negligence, with states in the country defining and quantifying the liability extents differently.

Gross Negligence

Gross negligence involves actions taken with a reckless disregard for the harmful consequences they may cause.

This type of negligence is the most serious form of negligence, often resulting in higher damages due to the severity of the oversight.

While gross negligence does not equate to an actual intent to cause harm, it goes beyond ordinary negligence.

Consider the case of a surgeon who performs surgery while under the influence of alcohol.

This situation is gross negligence due to the blatant disregard for the patient’s safety.

The surgeon’s impaired state significantly increases the risk of serious mistakes that can result in severe harm or even death.

Unlike ordinary negligence — which might involve a doctor missing a diagnosis that a competent doctor might also have missed — gross negligence displays a profound lack of care that exceeds any reasonable boundary.

Contributory Negligence

This type of negligence refers to situations where the plaintiff’s own negligent actions contributed to their injuries.

This principle operates on an all-or-nothing basis, which can have severe implications for plaintiffs with personal injury.

Imagine a pedestrian crossing the street while texting on their phone, ignoring the designated crosswalk.

Simultaneously, a driver is speeding and fails to stop at a red light, hitting the pedestrian.

In this case, both parties exhibit negligence; however, the pedestrian’s failure to adhere to traffic laws and remain vigilant contributed to the accident.

Contributory negligence is illustrated as the pedestrian’s actions contributed to causing their injuries, which may limit or completely bar their ability to recover damages in a car accident claim.

Comparative Negligence

The comparative negligence doctrine resulted from the harsh, unjust results under the previous negligence approach.

Under this doctrine, a plaintiff found partially at fault is still entitled to compensation.

The percentage of their own fault adjusts the amount.

Comparative negligence has two primary approaches: pure and modified comparative negligence.

Under pure comparative negligence, compensation is awarded based on the allocation of fault.

On the other hand, modified comparative negligence — also referred to as combined or mixed comparative and contributory negligence — prohibits a plaintiff from receiving compensation for their injuries if the percentage of their fault exceeds the threshold set by state law.

Vicarious Negligence

Vicarious negligence is when an entity or an individual is deemed liable for the negligent actions of another person.

This form of negligence — also known as vicarious liability — is frequently observed in employment settings, where an employer may be found and held liable for an employee’s negligence during their job responsibilities.

What Is Auto Negligence?

In driving, negligence occurs when a driver fails to exercise the level of caution or attentiveness expected under certain circumstances, resulting in car accidents.

This lack of proper care can manifest in various forms, with each action indicating a departure from the standard duty of care that a reasonable person behind the wheel would observe.

Negligent Driving vs Reckless Driving

Negligent and reckless driving are distinct legal concepts, though both involve a failure to adhere to safe driving practices.

Reckless driving is characterized by a willful disregard for the safety of other motorists, involving conduct that the driver knows or should know is likely to lead to harmful consequences.

The key difference is in the intent and awareness of risk; reckless driving indicates a higher level of culpability as it involves conscious decisions that pose a significant danger to others.

What Makes a Negligent Driver?

Several behaviors and actions commonly contribute to driver negligence, jeopardizing the safety of everyone on the road.

Identifying these actions can help you understand the root causes of many traffic accidents and emphasize the importance of following proper driving practices.

Speeding

Speeding is driving above the speed limit or too fast for prevailing conditions.

According to an AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety survey, more than half of all drivers partake in hazardous actions while driving, with speeding being the most prevalent cause of car accident cases.

Distraction

Engaging in activities that divert attention from safe driving — including texting, eating, or using in-car technologies — is another leading type of negligent driving.

Distracted driving prevents drivers from observing traffic signals, road conditions, and the actions of other drivers and pedestrians.

Failure To Yield

Not giving the right of way when required can cause collisions and other accidents, particularly at intersections.

This driver negligence often occurs when drivers are impatient or unaware of traffic rules, putting others at risk.

A driver who fails to yield when making a left turn at an intersection could hit a car coming from the opposite direction or a pedestrian crossing the street.

Impaired Driving

Operating a vehicle under the influence of drugs, alcohol, or medication that impairs cognitive and motor skills is a severe form of negligence.

Impaired drivers exhibit poor judgment, slower reaction times, and diminished coordination, making them a hazard to themselves and others.

Disobeying Traffic Signs and Signals

Ignoring stop signs, red lights, and other regulatory signals is negligent driving.

These signals manage traffic and ensure safety, and disobeying them shows a clear disregard for the rules of the road.

Negligence and Car Accident Claims

Negligence is a crucial factor in car accident claims because it establishes the foundation for determining liability and compensation.

In order for an injured party to receive compensation, they must prove that a negligent driver caused the accident and subsequent injuries.

This proof involves demonstrating four key elements.

The Negligent Driver’s Duty of Care

Generally, individuals and businesses are responsible for demonstrating reasonable caution and prudence when conducting activities that may impact others.

Duty of care means a driver must be mindful of others’ safety and follow traffic rules and laws.

A negligent driver’s duty of care includes:

• Operating their vehicle with care and attention
• Being mindful of others’ safety
• Following traffic rules and laws
• Maintaining a safe environment for other motorists and pedestrians

Every individual who goes behind the wheel is responsible for upholding this duty of care to avoid becoming a negligent driver.

Proving the Negligent Driver Breached Their Duty

There must be a breach of duty of care to establish that a driver was negligent in a car accident.

This occurs when the negligent driver fails to act up to the expected standard of care or engages in behavior that falls below what is reasonably expected.

Examples of negligent drivers breaching their duty include:

• Speeding
• Driving under the influence
• Failing to yield to pedestrians
• Engaging in distracted driving behaviors

A negligent driver who commits these acts has acted less carefully than a reasonable motorist would have, making them liable for any harm caused.

Causation Between the Negligent Driver’s Breach and Damages

If a person fails to behave prudently but does not cause harm, the lack of prudence alone will not result in a successful claim against the negligent driver.

For a claim to be valid, the negligent driver’s failure to act reasonably must be directly linked to the plaintiff’s injuries.

Important points about causation and the negligent driver:

• The negligent driver’s behavior must directly cause harm
• There must be a clear link between the driver’s negligence and injuries
• Without causation, the negligent driver cannot be held legally liable
• Even egregious negligence by the driver without resulting harm does not enable a claim

Establishing this causative link is essential for a victim to have a valid negligence claim against the negligent driver.

Damages Caused by the Negligent Driver

To be eligible for compensation in a claim against a negligent driver, the victim must have endured quantifiable harm as a direct result of the negligent driver’s behavior.

The harm caused by the negligent driver can include both tangible and intangible losses.

Quantifiable harm caused by a negligent driver may encompass:

• Medical expenses
• Property damage
• Lost wages
• Pain and suffering

If there is no measurable harm, there is no basis for a claim, even if the negligent driver engaged in extremely negligent behavior.

The negligence must cause actual damages to enable a victim to seek compensation from the negligent driver.

TorHoerman Law: Car Accident Attorneys

If you believe another’s negligence caused your accident, contact an experienced car accident lawyer.

An experienced car accident attorney can help in establishing fault by gathering and analyzing evidence.

Beyond determining liability, an experienced lawyer plays a significant role in negotiating with insurance companies for fair compensation for your injuries, losses, and suffering.

If negotiations fail, a car accident attorney is ready to litigate in court, advocating on your behalf for the justice and financial restitution you deserve.

There is no need to navigate the aftermath of a car accident on your own — seek the expertise of a dedicated lawyer to guide you through the process and fight for your rights.

Contact TorHoerman Law for a free consultation.

You can also use the chatbot on this page to find out if you qualify for the auto negligence lawsuit instantly.